NeutrogenaSmokey Kohl Eyeliner with Antioxidant Vitamin E, Water-Resistant & Smooth-Gliding Eyeliner Makeup, Smokey Gray, 0.014 oz

love this eyeliner. it goes on smoothly and washes off fairly easily

I have used Clinique liner for a long time and really like this one because it doesn’t smear and it’s easy to apply.

Does not smear

I got this after reading reviews about the issue with difficulty sharpening it. I found out the hard way that it twists up, DO NOT USE A SHARPENER. Once you’re past that, it’s pretty good liner. There is nothing on the box or the ad about this.

I have a hard time finding eyeliner that I can use on my water line because most make my eyes water like crazy. This one is great! It will smudge if your not careful but it doesn't irritate my eyes which is exactly what I was looking for!

This is about the only eyeliner I can wear that doesn't irritate my eyes, doesn't smudge and stays put all day.

Best eyeliner ever,glides on creamy,excellents shade lasts really well, best one I hve ever used!!

I was expecting a medium to light gray. This is almost as dark as black. Too harsh for me, a great grandmother..